This was our list of pies (stars by the ones I made):
*Pumpkin Butter Pecan
*Toll House Cookie
*Jello Cream Cheese
*Chocolate Crusted Peanut Butter (or Candy Bar Pie)
*Tart Au Citron
The most popular pies were the Dutch Apple, Buttermilk, Salted Caramel, and Snickerdoodle Apple. The least favorite was the Jello Cream Cheese. I don't think I'll bother making that one again. I also think I would limit any doubling up to only the very favorites. We had a pretty good crowd, but I think we can do better next year. The plan is to either invite WAY more people, or make a lot fewer pies. We ended up with SO MANY leftovers and were sending people home with and delivering plates full of different pie slices.
I also wish I had taken more photos of the guests and party. There's always next year!
Crusts prepped and ready to go!
Labels printed beside the Tart Au Citron and two Buttermilk Pies:
Part of the layout:
The Nielsons enjoying some pie:
Two awesome neighbors and friends - Natalie Dobbin and Dayna Olson. They were some of the very first to welcome us to the ward/neighborhood.
The aftermath.... The first is of our downstairs once all the kids got done
And of course, the kitchen:
It was a ton of work, but a LOT of fun. I love this unique party idea and I'm grateful we've adopted it from Miles' dad. We hope to have just as many years and more of Pie Parties!